Choosing the right airline for your transatlantic journey can be a tough decision, especially when comparing Norse Airways and Icelandair. Both carriers offer competitive fares between Europe and North America, but each has its own strengths, cabin experience, and unique selling points. This guide will walk you through the key differences to help you decide which airline best suits your travel style and budget.

An Overview of Norse Airways

Norse Airways, officially known as Norse Atlantic Airways, is a relatively new player in the low-cost, long-haul market. Launched in 2021, the airline focuses on affordable transatlantic flights with modern Dreamliner aircraft. Its mission is to bring budget-friendly options to passengers who want to cross the Atlantic without paying legacy carrier prices.

Norse Airways operates mainly out of Oslo, Norway, and offers nonstop flights to major U.S. cities like New York, Los Angeles, and Miami. Thanks to its young fleet of Boeing 787 Dreamliners, travelers can expect fuel-efficient planes, larger windows, and a quieter cabin environment compared to older aircraft.

An Overview of Icelandair

In contrast, Icelandair is a long-established carrier with a strong reputation for reliability and service. Operating since 1937, Icelandair uses its Reykjavik hub as a connecting point between North America and Europe. The airline is famous for its free stopover program, allowing passengers to spend up to seven days exploring Iceland without additional airfare.

While Icelandair is not technically a low-cost airline, it frequently offers competitive fares—especially for economy travelers willing to connect through Iceland. The fleet mainly consists of Boeing 757s and 737 MAX aircraft, known for their comfort on medium- and long-haul routes.

Cabin Experience and Seating

When it comes to cabin comfort, Norse Airways offers a clean, modern interior thanks to its Dreamliner fleet. Seats are configured in a 3-3-3 layout in economy, with ample legroom for budget travel. For those seeking a little extra, Norse has a Premium cabin featuring wider seats, additional recline, and priority boarding. Though Premium isn’t exactly business class, it can be a worthwhile upgrade on a long flight.

Icelandair’s cabins have a classic feel and generally offer slightly more seat padding compared to low-cost competitors. Economy class seats have a reasonable pitch, and the airline’s Saga Premium cabin functions more like a true business-lite experience, with more spacious seating, complimentary meals, and lounge access at select airports.

If a comfortable seat is your top priority and you’re willing to pay extra, Icelandair’s Saga Premium usually offers more perks than Norse Airways Premium.

In-Flight Entertainment and Wi-Fi

Entertainment options can be a deciding factor on long-haul flights. Icelandair offers personal seatback screens across all classes, with a wide selection of movies, TV shows, and music. Additionally, Wi-Fi is available on most aircraft, though it comes at an extra charge.

Norse Airways also provides seatback entertainment on its Dreamliners, but in keeping with the low-cost model, you may need to pay for access depending on your fare class. Wi-Fi isn’t universally available yet, which could be a drawback if staying connected is essential for you.

Baggage Policies

Another area where these airlines differ is baggage allowance. Norse Airways follows an ultra-low-cost model, meaning your basic fare includes only a small under-seat personal item. Carry-on bags, checked luggage, meals, and seat selection are all charged separately. If you don’t plan carefully, these extras can quickly add up.

Icelandair fares are generally more inclusive. Economy Standard tickets include one carry-on and one checked bag, while Economy Light fares are more restrictive. If you value the simplicity of knowing your luggage is covered in the price, Icelandair is likely the better choice.

Onboard Catering

Catering also varies significantly. Norse Airways offers buy-on-board snacks, meals, and drinks in economy class. Premium passengers receive complimentary meals and beverages. Reviews of the food are generally positive for a low-cost carrier.

Icelandair provides complimentary soft drinks and water in economy, but full meals must be purchased on Economy Light and Standard fares. Saga Premium includes full meal service with wine and cocktails.

Stopover vs. Nonstop Convenience

Perhaps the most unique selling point of Icelandair is the ability to enjoy a free stopover in Iceland. This is an excellent opportunity to explore Reykjavik, visit the Blue Lagoon, or see the northern lights, all without additional airfare. However, this means you must connect through Reykjavik rather than flying nonstop.

Norse Airways, by contrast, focuses on nonstop routes. If you prefer to get to your destination as quickly as possible without layovers, Norse might be the more convenient option.

Price Comparison

Pricing is where Norse Airways often stands out. For travelers who pack light and skip extras, Norse typically beats Icelandair on basic fares. But once you add baggage, meals, and seat selection, the gap narrows. Icelandair’s bundled fares can provide better value if you prefer more inclusions upfront.

The Verdict: Which Airline Should You Choose?

If you’re seeking the lowest possible fare and a nonstop flight on a modern Dreamliner, Norse Airways is an excellent choice. Just be prepared to pay for any extras you want.

On the other hand, if you prefer a more traditional airline experience, included baggage, and the option to stop in Iceland, Icelandair is worth the extra cost.