If you’ve been grinding MLB The Show 25 for even a few weeks, chances are your inventory is stacked with duplicate cards—especially common players, uniforms, perks, and sponsorships. While these extras may seem like clutter, they’re actually a solid source of extra Stubs if you know how to manage them strategically. Here’s how to turn 25 duplicates into a respectable stash of MLB The Show 25 Stubs—and how to get even more value from your trades.

1. Audit Your Inventory Weekly

Before you jump into selling, take a moment to organize. Head to your “My Inventory” tab and use filters to spot duplicates. Sort by quantity and rarity. Look for cards where you own more than one—especially Bronze and Silver cards. You’d be surprised how much they go for when certain collections are hot.

2. Prioritize Players in Active Collections

Some player items are more valuable than others purely because they’re needed in current collection programs. Check the Market Trends section and Community Market to see which teams or series are trending. If any of your duplicates match those sets, you can get a better price selling now rather than quick-selling.

3. Use the Sell Order System, Not Quick Sell

Quick-selling may be faster, but it often leaves Stubs on the table. Instead, list your duplicates on the market using the “Sell Order” feature. You can undercut slightly and still make more than the flat quick-sell price. For example, a Silver card might quick-sell for 100 Stubs, but easily go for 175-200 on the market if it’s needed in a mission.

4. Watch the 24-Hour Fluctuations

Some cards fluctuate in value depending on the time of day or new content drops. Friday and Sunday evenings tend to have high buyer activity due to pack openings and event refreshes. Listing your duplicates during these windows can help you maximize your return.

5. Combine With Packs and Rewards

Every time you open a pack from Conquest, Battle Royale, or Ranked Seasons, set a habit to review for duplicates. Even non-sellable items sometimes unlock exchanges that lead to packs or cards that are sellable. Trading in 25 duplicates across categories can easily net you several thousand Stubs over time.

6. Set Stub Goals and Track Profits

Just like flipping investments, it helps to track what you're making from duplicate trades. If you turn 25 unwanted cards into, say, 4,000 Stubs, that’s a solid return—especially when you're building toward a goal like a Diamond player or an expensive equipment item. Some players choose to reinvest these profits, while others prefer to save or buy MLB The Show 25 Stubs when there’s a promo or player they really want.

7. When to Buy Instead of Grind

Let’s be honest: sometimes grinding the market just isn't worth the time—especially for high-end cards. In those cases, players often look for the best place to buy Stubs MLB The Show 25. Sites like U4N are commonly used by the community for fast top-ups, especially when seasonal content drops or new Signature Series cards hit the store. While trading duplicates is great for budget-friendly players, buying a few Stubs can accelerate your progress significantly if you’re chasing elite cards or sets.

Final Thoughts

Trading 25 duplicates won’t make you a millionaire overnight, but it’s a dependable and consistent way to build your balance—especially for free-to-play players. By combining smart inventory management with strategic market play, you can keep your Stubs balance healthy without wasting resources. And when you’re ready to make a big purchase or want to skip the grind, you can always buy MLB The Show 25 Stubs through trusted community sites like U4N. Just be sure to check timing, value, and your goals before committing your Stubs or cash.