Shopping online for open toe heels is convenient, exciting, and often full of surprises—some good, some not so great. While online stores offer a wider selection than most brick-and-mortar shops, buying shoes without trying them on can be tricky. From sizing concerns to style choices, there are a few things you’ll want to keep in mind before clicking “add to cart.”

Here’s everything you should know before buying open toe heels online, so you can shop with confidence and step out in style.

1. Know Your True Shoe Size (and Width)

Sizing can vary drastically between brands and even between different heel styles. Before you buy, measure your feet at home and compare the numbers with the brand’s sizing chart. Be sure to account for both length and width, especially if you’re shopping for narrow or wide open toe heels.

Pro tip: If you’re between sizes, it’s usually safer to size up and use heel pads or insoles for a better fit.

2. Check Return and Exchange Policies

Open toe heels may look perfect in pictures, but if they don’t feel comfortable or don’t fit your feet properly, you'll want the option to return or exchange them. Always read the store’s return policy before buying. Look for details on return windows, restocking fees, and whether return shipping is free or not.

If you're buying during a sale, double-check that sale items are eligible for return—many aren’t.

3. Read the Reviews

Customer reviews are gold when it comes to shopping online. Look for feedback about fit, comfort, color accuracy, and heel height. You’ll often find helpful tips from people who’ve worn the shoes with everything from jeans to flowy skirts and women’s tops.

Some reviewers even post photos, giving you a real-life look at the heels outside of the polished product images.

4. Pay Attention to Material and Heel Height

Photos can be deceiving, especially when it comes to the materials used in open toe heels. Always check the product description for fabric type—genuine leather, synthetic, suede, or patent—and consider how each wears over time.

Also, consider the heel height. A pair of 4-inch stilettos might look stunning, but are they practical for daily wear? Think about how and where you’ll wear them—whether it's date night, work, or pairing with cute women's tops for brunch.

Conclusion

Buying open toe heels online doesn’t have to be a gamble. By taking the time to understand sizing, checking return policies, reading reviews, and carefully evaluating materials and heel height, you’ll be setting yourself up for a successful purchase. Open toe heels are versatile, stylish, and the perfect companion to everything from dresses to your favorite pair of jeans and women’s tops. Shop smart, and your perfect pair is just a few clicks away.